Breaking News

UK Says Bulawayo is More Tolerant To Homosexuals

by Ndou Paul
15 February 2012 | 3372 Views
 United Kingdom based online News website the NewZimbabwe.Com reports that ZIMBABWEAN s claiming asylum in the UK are more than likely to be turned down because the country has a thriving "gay scene" Bulawayo being the most tolerant city to practice  homosexuality.

In a recent landmark judgement, the UK's Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) left the door slightly ajar for asylum claimants whose personal circumstances place them at risk or suffer from HIV.

A Zimbabwean asylum seeker, known by the initials LZ, arrived in the United Kingdom in 1999. She claimed asylum in 2009, stating that she feared persecution as a lesbian back home.

The UK Home Office turned down her asylum bid leading to the case reaching the Upper Tribunal of the Immigration and Asylum Chamber.

In its judgment described as "significant" by immigration lawyers, the Upper Tribunal said it was "unable to accept that homosexuals are being persecuted as a generality when concrete examples are few, and when that standpoint is not supported by the best placed local observers".

Finding that there has been much public expression of extreme homophobia at the highest levels in recent years, including by President Robert Mugabe and Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, Justices Macleman and Holmes went on: "Male homosexual behaviour is criminalised, but prosecutions are very rare. Lesbianism is not criminalised...

"There are no records of any murders with a homophobic element. ‘Corrective rape' is rare, and does not represent a general risk.

"There is a ‘gay scene' within limitations."

The judges also noted that lesbians, living on their own or together, may face greater difficulties than gay men.

But the court was heavily swayed by a submission by the Gays and Lesbians Association of Zimbabwe (GALZ) which told a UK Border Agency fact finding mission that Zimbabwe is "not the worst place in the world to be gay or lesbian even though the President, government officials and church leaders have whipped up a climate of hysterical homophobia."

Applying a standard set in an earlier ruling in HJ & HT, Judge Holmes and Judge Mclean said "there is no general risk to gays or lesbians" in Zimbabwe.

"The perception that a woman is a lesbian may lead to discrimination or harassment from some individuals, but not generally to violence. There is a higher level of tolerance of homosexuality within Zimbabwean society than government rhetoric would suggest," the judges found.

The Tribunal, using information supplied by GALZ, went on to suggest that there were different tolerance levels for homosexuals in Zimbabwe, with Bulawayo seen as most tolerant.

"A homosexual at risk in his or her community can move elsewhere, either in the same city or to another part of the country. He or she might choose to relocate to where there is greater tolerance, such as Bulawayo, but the choice of a new area is not restricted."

LZ's application failed on the general risk test, but was allowed after the Upper Tribunal said there could be "personal circumstances" that would place homosexuals at risk.

The court ruled that "although not decisive on its own, being openly gay may increase risk. A positive HIV/AIDS diagnosis may also be a risk factor."

Homosexuality is hogging the public debates in Zimbabwe as the country prepares for a referendum on a new constitution.

By a wide majority, most Zimbabweans are opposed to homosexuality and would like to see the retention of laws criminalising same sex relationships.

In January 2012 suspected Zanu PF youths destroyed litter bins that were donated to the Bulawayo City Council by the Sexual Rights Centre,(a gays and lesbian rights organisation)  after inscribing them Pasi Nengochani (Down with homosexuality).

Below are photos of the litter bins curtsey of The Southern Star






      





Homosexuals

Source: newzimbabwe.com

Should airtime and street vendors pay the $1 a day State levy?

Yes
11.16%
No
82.66%
Desperation
6.18%
842

Comments

News Updates

Email:

Latest News

Bleeding ear sends nurses into panic - Lack of knowledge about how the...

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2006 Views

Housing associations under check in Harare - The sprouting of resident...

by Staff Reporter | 29 August 2014 | 895 Views

Zim govt signs mining deal with Chinese company - The government and a...

by Staff Reporter | 29 August 2014 | 1093 Views

BCC statement on water cuts in Bulawayo - CITY OF BULAWAYOPRESS RELEAS...

by Staff Reporter | 29 August 2014 | 1625 Views

Murdered pregnant woman found without the foetus - POLICE are investig...

by Kingstone Mapupu | 29 August 2014 | 2566 Views

Hubby assaults wife over conjugal rights - AN octogenarian from Marang...

by Clara Mudefi | 29 August 2014 | 2206 Views

Granny burnt to death - A 90-YEAR-OLD Chipinge granny was last week bu...

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 1228 Views

Hefty headman's fine leads to suicide - FAILURE to stomach a hefty fin...

by Luthando Mapepa | 29 August 2014 | 1562 Views

Unseen stones pelt boy (12)

by Ray Bande | 29 August 2014 | 1854 Views

Efforts to save little Russell fruitful

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 1326 Views

Politics without 'Chimurenga' is vague - In as much as Zimbabweans fro...

by Caitlin Kamba | 29 August 2014 | 1461 Views

Tribal tensions in Matebeleland as land row widens - The people of Mat...

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2871 Views

'Zimdollar return suicidal,' says RBZ boss - Government should not re...

by Taurai Mangudhla | 29 August 2014 | 2288 Views

Mugabe confronts Mavhaire over factionalism - THE Zanu-PF succession d...

by Elias Mambo | 29 August 2014 | 3802 Views

Let's resolve Medical Aid Societies and Health Service providers impas...

by Suitable Kajau | 29 August 2014 | 1202 Views

Let's revisit death penalty now - Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Af...

by Suitable Kajau | 29 August 2014 | 1775 Views

Prince Harry's Zimbabwean ex to wed - The ex-girlfriend of Britain's ...

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 3993 Views

Dembare's Mutuma, Murape kiss and make-up

by Augustine Hwata | 29 August 2014 | 2401 Views

Magistrate probed for abuse of office - A Masvingo magistrate, Jabulan...

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 1912 Views

Exiled fugitive secessionist predicts Zanu-PF implosion - EXILED fugit...

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2854 Views

Bulawayo sues Econet

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2450 Views

'Prophet' tells family to undress, steal their money

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2663 Views

Zanu-PF invaders thrown out of Dabengwa's farm by police - ABOUT 150 Z...

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2278 Views

Sinda Ngulube elected new BICC bishop - THE Brethren in Christ Church ...

by Staff reporter | 29 August 2014 | 1070 Views

Wife tells hubby to quench 'sexual thirst' on their daughter

by Prosper Dembedza | 29 August 2014 | 4238 Views

Mnangagwa's name used for fraud

by Fungai Lupande | 29 August 2014 | 1526 Views

Mutambara's former aide jailed

by Court Reporter | 29 August 2014 | 1594 Views

Wife starves HIV+ hubby - An HIV-positive man yesterday told the Hara...

by Court Reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2153 Views

Entertainment

ZBC receives TV programmes from South Korea - The Korean Ambassador to...

by Staff Reporter | 29 August 2014 | 940 Views

Roki cancels SA show

by Sophia Chese | 29 August 2014 | 1236 Views

Zimbabwe Got Talent on the cards - CHINESE Federation of Zimbabwe (CFZ...

by Staff reporter | 28 August 2014 | 1307 Views

Tuku to Deliver Inaugural Hugh Masekela Lecture

by Staff Reporter | 28 August 2014 | 1413 Views

Controversy over Bev's album - Newly-appointed Msasa Bricks Ambassador...

by Staff reporter | 27 August 2014 | 2008 Views

Viewers slam 'sub-standard' ZBCtv program - VARIOUS ZBCtv viewers have...

by Staff reporter | 27 August 2014 | 2102 Views

John Legend cancels Zimbabwe show

by Showbiz Reporter | 27 August 2014 | 4317 Views

Macheso's yet to be released album sold on Harare streets - Pirates ha...

by Staff reporter | 26 August 2014 | 2958 Views