Zimbabwe legalise land grabs in new constitution
2012 July 25 13:06:51 | 2110 Views
- Ingabe ikuphatheleni i-MDC, njalo kusizani ukuyivotela? | 2013 May 13 17:03:55 | 2985 views
- Ikuphatheleni iMDC, kusiza ngani ukuyivotela? | 2013 May 08 19:28:47 | 2825 views
- MDC-T on course | 2013 March 27 14:05:12 | 6721 views
- People will vote for a party with sustainable economic programmes | 2013 March 04 02:36:52 | 7504 views
- Introducing: Election (2013) campaign articles | 2013 March 02 11:08:41 | 6082 views
- Mugabe to sign new Constitution into law today | 2013 May 22 06:25:08
- Constitution awaits Mugabe's signature | 2013 May 15 09:10:54
- Constitutional Bill sails through Senate with amendments | 2013 May 15 05:55:17
- Tsvangirai's position to cease when a new govt is sworn in | 2013 April 11 09:16:51
- Lawyer warns of looming constitutional crisis | 2013 April 02 08:42:48
- Prostitute dies during love making, 'resurrects' in coffin | 2013 March 23 10:13:12 | 85161 views
- Woman sends photo of naked President Mugabe via Whatsapp | 2013 January 10 15:04:10 | 46526 views
- Zim woman who had sex with boyfriend as son watched named | 2013 January 31 09:05:43 | 44930 views
- Man marries mother-in-law after his wife died | 2013 January 16 11:05:42 | 30585 views
The new document, which has taken over three years and many millions of dollars to complete, is already being criticised as a deeply flawed product of negotiation. Analysts from both sides of Zimbabwe's gaping political divide have criticised the proposed charter, while other observers have said the MDC has "given in" to Zanu-PF.
But one element that is clearly in Zanu-PF's favour is the section on land.
The draft document enshrines the right of the state to seize land, while also guaranteeing land invaders the right to the properties they seize. The draft states that all agricultural land, including forestry land, conservation land and horticultural land, among others, may be "acquired" by the State for "public purpose." The takeovers will also be done without compensation according to the new charter and compensation issues cannot be challenged in the courts.
The draft also stipulates that legal challenges to the state takeover of land may not be on the ground that it was "discriminatory."
The draft constitution also upholds the standards of the old charter by insisting that Britain is responsible for compensation for the land seized as part of the land grab. The draft states that "the former colonial power has an obligation to pay compensation for agricultural land," and if this fails to happen "the Government of Zimbabwe has no obligation."
This provision flies in the face of a 2008 ruling in the Southern African Human Rights Court, which ruled that the land grab was unlawful. It ordered the then Zanu-PF led government to compensate the farmers who lost land, saying the land seizures were "inherently discriminatory."
Zimbabwe's new charter however makes the legal provision for this regional ruling to be ignored, and goes further to enshrine the rights of current and future land invaders.
The document states that anyone "using or occupying" property before the constitution comes into effect, "continues to be entitled to use or occupy that land" when the charter becomes effective.
Douglas Mwonzora, the MDC-T spokesman and key party official heading the constitution rewriting exercise, told SW Radio Africa on Monday that there are "difficulties" in the land clauses, arguing that the product is one that had to be negotiated with Zanu-PF.
But he insisted that the provisions ensure that land acquisitions in the future, when sanctioned by the state, will be done "legally," because the state take over of properties will be provided for in this new charter.
John Worsley-Worswick from Justice for Agriculture (JAG) meanwhile said the clauses on land are concerning "because there are few changes to the old constitution."
"We are alarmed," Worsley-Worswick said, emphasising the need for property rights to be secured for the future of Zimbabwe. He also agreed that Zimbabwe was appearing to legitimise land seizures with this document.
"For this country to move forward you need stability in agriculture, because Zimbabwe is essentially an agriculture based economy. But this constitution does not allow for any stability," Worsley-Worswick said.
Source: SW Radio
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 639 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 689 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 743 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 1601 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 472 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 1091 Views
Business reporter | 2013 May 22 | 1427 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 969 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 2233 Views
Business reporter | 2013 May 22 | 598 Views
Ben Chiganze | 2013 May 22 | 966 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 937 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 617 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 1221 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 653 Views
Prosper Ndlovu | 2013 May 22 | 705 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 22 | 965 Views
Court Reporter | 2013 May 22 | 1316 Views
Charles Laiton | 2013 May 22 | 1082 Views
Jairos Saunyama | 2013 May 22 | 761 Views
Own Correspondent | 2013 May 22 | 1786 Views
blackvoicenews.com | 2013 May 22 | 746 Views
Agencies | 2013 May 22 | 450 Views
Staff Reporter | 2013 May 21 | 2400 Views
Blessing Ivan Vava | 2013 May 21 | 1195 Views
Staff reporter | 2013 May 21 | 3810 Views
Moyo Roy | 2013 May 20 | 4650 Views
TMZ | 2013 May 20 | 2059 Views
Emmanuel Ndlovu | 2013 May 18 | 2125 Views
Arts reporter | 2013 May 17 | 2070 Views
Entertainment Correspondent | 2013 May 17 | 2800 Views
Moyo Roy | 2013 May 16 | 2270 Views
Vasco Shaya | 2013 May 16 | 4207 Views