Breaking News

Legal wrangle looms over awarding Mtshabezi tender

by Staff reporter
2012 July 17 01:35:01 | 1501 Views

Tags

Bulawayo,

Most Viewed

A legal wrangle is looming over the awarding of a tender for the electrification of the Mtshabezi pipeline with a Bulawayo company, United Associates (Pvt) Ltd, approaching the Administrative Court, the Chronicle reported.

The State Procurement Board is cited as the 1st respondent in the application while A.C Controls (Pvt) Ltd is the 2nd respondent.

The State Procurement Board recently came under fire from business people and prospective bidders on allegations of corruptly awarding tenders to their “favoured” bidders.

Prospective bidders from Bulawayo and surrounding areas alleged a lack of transparency in the State Procurement Board, saying it was bringing companies from Harare to take up tenders yet there would be many other bidders meeting specifications.

The problem reportedly emerges when such bidders fail to deliver or provide sub-standard service while also bringing workers from Harare.

The matter of the Mtshabezi water project electrification tender has now spilled to the courts as United Associates (Pvt) Ltd seeks an order nullifying the tender awarded to A.C Controls and that it be awarded to them.

On 20 January this year, the State Procurement Board invited tenders for the electrification of the Mtshabezi pipeline.

Tenders were opened on 21 February after a site visit on 31 January.

On 14 May, United Associates received a letter dated 16 April from the State Procurement Board advising them that the tender had been awarded to the second respondent.

In their Notice of Appeal filed by the company through their lawyer, Mr Shepherd Chamunorwa, of Calderwood, Bryce Hendrie and Partners, United Associates say the decision by the State Procurement Board to award the tender to the 2nd respondent is grossly outrageous in its defiance of logic that no reasonable tribunal faced with the same facts would have made the award to the second respondent.

The company said their bid was rejected because it allegedly did not submit proof of contracting category, did not submit quotations, did not state the terms of payments and did not submit a method statement.

“On the other hand, the 2nd respondent was held to be ‘fully compliant’. It is not apparent on what consideration they were deemed to be so.

“The 1st respondent failed to take into account a number of material considerations, namely that the bid submitted by the appellant was lower than the one for the 2nd respondent and that the appellant has the same as, or better than capacity to the 2nd respondent to carry out the project that the parties had tendered for,” wrote United Associates (Pvt) Ltd.

It is their contention that adjudication process was not transparent and was amenable to abuse by members or official of the State Procurement Board.

They prayed to the court to set aside the award to the 2nd respondent and order that the tender be awarded to them or alternatively that the tender be started de novo on such terms as the court may deem fit.

Despite the filing of the Notice of Appeal, the State Procurement Board has reportedly failed to comply because once an appeal is noted work should stop.

Last month, the Minister of Water Resources, Management and Development, Samuel Sipepa Nkomo blamed delays in awarding tenders by the State Procurement Board in the latest failure to beat the completion of the Mtshabezi-Umzingwane pipeline.

“They delayed in making a resolution regarding the procurement of motors and pumps and also delayed in awarding the tender for power lines that will bring electricity from Gwanda.

“The buildings and the pipeline have been completed and we are now waiting for the pumps to be brought from South Africa and installed.

“We will use generators until power has been connected,” said Minister Nkomo.






Source: TC

Comments

News Updates

Email:

Latest News

Zimbabwean defender ready to dump Zimbabwe for Zambia - A Zimbabwean d...

by Sports reporter | 2013 May 25 | 34 Views

Top CIO's death divides Zanu-PF - THE death of Central Intelligence Or...

by Staff reporter | 2013 May 25 | 100 Views

Mugabe told Sally about extra marital affair with Grace

by Staff reporter | 2013 May 25 | 101 Views

Peter Ndlovu rallies home-based Warriors - LEGENDARY Zimbabwean footba...

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 1035 Views

Donkeys bite man (65) to death

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 1955 Views

Robert Sinyoka - neglected and almost forgotten - ROBERT Sinyoka, a st...

by Nqobani Ndlovu | 2013 May 25 | 1144 Views

U.S. President, Obama, seeks to end 'war on terror'

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 436 Views

U.S. concerned Syrian war could spill into Lebanon

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 232 Views

African Union celebrates Golden Jubilee - THE African Union today achi...

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 444 Views

Air Zim gets a new Airbus A320

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 1208 Views

Chitungwiza blast victims houses rebuilding starts

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 727 Views

Homeless man rapes street girl (12) - A 22-year-old vagrant was on W...

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 1595 Views

Delegates from 13 countries arrive for carnival - Delegates from 13 co...

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 25 | 809 Views

Zimbabwean man gets two life terms for farm murders in SA

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 24 | 2512 Views

Eleven Asiagate players' future uncertain - Eleven local football play...

by Sports reporter | 2013 May 24 | 2464 Views

Oscar Machapa offloaded by Moroka Swallows - Zimbabwean casualties in ...

by Sports reporter | 2013 May 24 | 1612 Views

Fighter Jets scramble in UK, Pakistan passenger Plane held

by Staff Reporter | 2013 May 24 | 2174 Views

ZSE: Industrials advances to cap record week - ZSE's Industrials conti...

by Business reporter | 2013 May 24 | 964 Views

Blogs

IMPORTANT Voter & Citizenship Info for Zimbabwe-born residents with SA...

by Staff reporter | 2013 May 09 | 4818 Views

Hitchhiker's guide to designing a successful life - Success is a major...

by Regenesys.co.za | 2013 April 04 | 4037 Views

Let us promote our mother languages - Shona and Ndebele are the two l...

by John Gambanga | 2013 April 02 | 2263 Views

Entertainment

Zimbabwe Big Brother Africa housemate is - THE wait for the most antic...

by Chenai Nyakunengwa Lifestyle Writer | 2013 May 25 | 93 Views

Mkhululi Bhebhe to lead in worship at HICC

by Lifestyle Writer | 2013 May 25 | 43 Views

Studio 263 director Godwin Mawuru dies - It is a sad day for the Zimb...

by Arts reporter | 2013 May 24 | 3492 Views

3 band members desert Macheso - Popular sungura musician Alick Macheso...

by Arts Correspondent | 2013 May 24 | 2452 Views

'DJ Munya hired hitmen' - MURDER suspect Star FM DJ Munyaradzi Milimo ...

by Staff reporter | 2013 May 23 | 3575 Views

Royal Destiny - 'Lord I Believe'

by Moyo Roy | 2013 May 23 | 1403 Views

Mi Casa behind the scenes at HIFA - Behind the scenes footage of Mi Ca...

by Staff reporter | 2013 May 23 | 1486 Views

Jeys Marabini - The Pride of Bulawayo - Blessing Ivan Vava, a freelanc...

by Blessing Ivan Vava | 2013 May 21 | 2099 Views