News / National
High Court stops searches at Obert Mpofu, Goche and Kasukuwere's offices
15 Mar 2013 at 05:56hrs | Views
THE High Court has stopped the Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission from conducting searches at the offices of the National Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board.
On Monday ZACC obtained search warrants from the High Court to search and seize certain documents from the offices of three Government ministers - Mines and Mining Development Minister Obert Mpofu, Youth Development, Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Minister Saviour Kasukuwere and Transport, Communications and Infrastructure Development Minister Nicholas Goche.
ZACC suspects the trio was involved in underhand dealings.
On Tuesday NIEEB and the Zimbabwe Mining Development Corporation sought an interdict through an urgent chamber application that saw Judge President George Chiweshe ruling in their favour.For convenience, the two matters were jointly heard and Justice Chiweshe passed one ruling which has a bearing on both matters.
Justice Chiweshe granted the order with the consent of ZACC, which conceded to the terms of the interim relief sought by ZMDC and NIEEB without any amendment. He barred ZACC from executing the search warrant issued by the High Court on March 11.
NIEEB falls under Minister Kasukuwere's portifolio.
ZACC obtained search warrants after its investigators were reportedly denied entry to conduct searches at the three offices.
NIEEB, in its application that also cited Police Commissioner-General Augustine Chihuri and the Attorney-General Mr Johannes Tomana as respondents, sought a provisional order stopping ZACC from executing the search warrants obtained from the same court on Monday pending the determination of the matter.
It argued that the search warrants that were obtained in terms of Section 50(1) of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act, were wrongly issued.
The indigenisation board also argued that ZACC had no power in terms of its own enabling legislation, the Anti-Corruption Commission Act, to obtain a search warrant from a judge of the High Court.
Mr Wilson Gwatiringa, an official from NIEEB, who deposed the affidavit, stated that ZACC acted ultravires its own enabling Act to exercise power, which it does not have.
He said the commission caused the higher court to issue a search warrant in circumstances where the judge concerned did not have the power to do so in view of the section of the law relied upon.
He said the execution of the illegal search warrant would disrupt NIEEB's operations and irreparably prejudice the successful execution of the indigenisation programme.
Mr Gwatiringa added that NIEEB had a right to protection of the law in circumstances where a party such as ZACC acts in clear violation of its own enabling Act as well as the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act.
The commission approached the High Court on Monday and obtained the search warrant after Harare magistrate Ms Marehwanazvo Gofa refused to grant its application for lack of merit.
In her ruling, Ms Gofa said she was not convinced that ZACC had satisfied the requirements of the provisions of the for such application to be granted.
Section 13(4) of the Anti-Corruption Act requires any officer who intends to make any search, entry or seizure to first notify the officer commanding the police district in which the officer intends to make the search, entry or seizure and secondly to be accompanied by a police officer assigned to him or her.
ZACC general manager for investigations Ms Sukai Tongogara had sought an order allowing the commission to search the three ministers' offices and secure a plethora of documents, which she said would assist in the investigation of the alleged corrupt deals.
On Monday ZACC obtained search warrants from the High Court to search and seize certain documents from the offices of three Government ministers - Mines and Mining Development Minister Obert Mpofu, Youth Development, Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Minister Saviour Kasukuwere and Transport, Communications and Infrastructure Development Minister Nicholas Goche.
ZACC suspects the trio was involved in underhand dealings.
On Tuesday NIEEB and the Zimbabwe Mining Development Corporation sought an interdict through an urgent chamber application that saw Judge President George Chiweshe ruling in their favour.For convenience, the two matters were jointly heard and Justice Chiweshe passed one ruling which has a bearing on both matters.
Justice Chiweshe granted the order with the consent of ZACC, which conceded to the terms of the interim relief sought by ZMDC and NIEEB without any amendment. He barred ZACC from executing the search warrant issued by the High Court on March 11.
NIEEB falls under Minister Kasukuwere's portifolio.
ZACC obtained search warrants after its investigators were reportedly denied entry to conduct searches at the three offices.
NIEEB, in its application that also cited Police Commissioner-General Augustine Chihuri and the Attorney-General Mr Johannes Tomana as respondents, sought a provisional order stopping ZACC from executing the search warrants obtained from the same court on Monday pending the determination of the matter.
It argued that the search warrants that were obtained in terms of Section 50(1) of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act, were wrongly issued.
Mr Wilson Gwatiringa, an official from NIEEB, who deposed the affidavit, stated that ZACC acted ultravires its own enabling Act to exercise power, which it does not have.
He said the commission caused the higher court to issue a search warrant in circumstances where the judge concerned did not have the power to do so in view of the section of the law relied upon.
He said the execution of the illegal search warrant would disrupt NIEEB's operations and irreparably prejudice the successful execution of the indigenisation programme.
Mr Gwatiringa added that NIEEB had a right to protection of the law in circumstances where a party such as ZACC acts in clear violation of its own enabling Act as well as the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act.
The commission approached the High Court on Monday and obtained the search warrant after Harare magistrate Ms Marehwanazvo Gofa refused to grant its application for lack of merit.
In her ruling, Ms Gofa said she was not convinced that ZACC had satisfied the requirements of the provisions of the for such application to be granted.
Section 13(4) of the Anti-Corruption Act requires any officer who intends to make any search, entry or seizure to first notify the officer commanding the police district in which the officer intends to make the search, entry or seizure and secondly to be accompanied by a police officer assigned to him or her.
ZACC general manager for investigations Ms Sukai Tongogara had sought an order allowing the commission to search the three ministers' offices and secure a plethora of documents, which she said would assist in the investigation of the alleged corrupt deals.
Source - TH