News / National
Mnangagwa accused of bribing chiefs
15 Jan 2018 at 16:05hrs | Views
Zimbabwe's main opposition party along with rights groups have accused President Emmerson Mnangagwa of bribing chiefs with cars in exchange for votes.
This comes after Mnangagwa splurged a fortune on 52 brand new double cab cars for traditional leaders, in a move that has been roundly condemned as "sickening vote-buying" by Zanu PF ahead of the watershed polls - and not withstanding other more urgent needs.
Mnangagwa and his deputy, Constantino Chiwenga, handed over the cars in Gweru on Saturday after meeting with 286 traditional chiefs.
He said the rest of the cars were on their way.
Rights groups and the opposition allege that in return of the privileges, the chiefs are expected to render unconditional support for Mnangagwa and his lieutenants in Zanu PF and act as agents of the electoral authoritarian ruling regime in the do-or-die 2018 general polls.
Mnangagwa, who ascended to power last November in a military coup that toppled veteran ruler Robert Mugabe, faces a tough challenge in the presidential vote being held alongside parliamentary and municipal ballots around mid this year.
The main opposition MDC said traditional leaders were obliged to be non-political actors by the supreme law of the land.
"Of course, . . . Mnangagwa is smelling a humiliating defeat at the hands of the MDC in the forthcoming elections; thus, he is desperately trying to garner support from the country's traditional leaders to enable them to virtually coerce their subjects to vote for Zanu PF," MDC spokesperson Obert Gutu told the Daily News.
"However, this strategy will not work because the majority of the chiefs and other traditional leaders are very smart people. They don't want to be used as Zanu PF's political commissars.
"The time of the hand-over of the motor vehicles to chiefs is obviously meant to compromise them and make them willing tools of the Zanu PF regime. This will not work because the chiefs know that the Zanu PF regime, even under . . . Mugabe, was never genuinely interested in looking after their welfare."
Stephen Chan, a professor of world politics at the School of Oriental and African Studies at the University of London in the United Kingdom, said as far as he can see, Mnangagwa has continued a practice borrowed from the Mugabe era.
"I disagree with it but it is, unfortunately, a common political phenomenon in many parts of Africa," opined Chan.
Gladys Hlatywayo, a political analyst and civil rights campaigner, said it was sad that the Mnangagwa administration was demonstrating each day that it is not different from the previous regime.
"They continue to use the same tactics and strategies and, personally, I struggle to see the so-called ‘new dispensation'. It is a case of misplaced priorities given the state of the economy," she said.
Zimbabwe's economy is deep in the throes of a debilitating economic crisis, which has led to horrendous company closures and the consequent loss of hundreds of thousands of jobs.
Life has therefore become more and more unbearable for millions of long-suffering Zimbabweans, as the local economy continues to die amid a severe shortage of cash.
Hlatywayo said the timing of Mnangagwa's benevolence points to the motive.
"Like the previous administration, this administration seeks to use traditional leaders to mobilise on its behalf ahead of upcoming elections," she said.
The Mugabe regime was known for valorising the traditional leadership institution, showering them with gifts such as vehicles, farms, farm machinery, generators, houses, mobile phones, fuel and electricity, and effectively making them agents of coercion, contrary to their much-vaunted role as custodians of national culture and traditional values.
Dewa Mavhinga, head of the Human Rights Watch Southern Africa, said there was no difference between Mnangagwa and Mugabe when it comes to Zanu PF's relationship with chiefs.
"The timing of the car gifts to chiefs ahead of elections could point to inducements for chiefs to support and campaign for Zanu PF in violation of the Constitution which requires chiefs to be strictly non-partisan. It points to misplaced priorities when hospitals lack basic medicines and equipment," he said.
Analyst Tamuka Charles Chirimambowa said each car can buy four tractors and with 230 cars, you have close to a 1 000 tractors that could have boosted farmers.
"The buying of cars is consumption economics and if he would have bought something like tractors, that's production economics," he said.
Analyst Xwayani Hope Msipha said the dishing out of cars to chiefs was a clear political move done by a party conscious of the need to seal the rural areas from the opposition.
Mugabe built a massive wall of fear for the rural people — who constitute 75 percent of the Zimbabwean voter bloc — maintaining control over the rural vote by directing ordinary voters to give their ballot-paper serial numbers to their village headmen, who would have marshalled the voters to the polling station and made them queue in a predetermined order, blatantly violating the sanctity of the vote.
Intimidated villagers willingly voted for Zanu PF, and those who disobeyed this instruction were ruthlessly punished — commanded to sprawl on the ground, sometimes naked, then clobbered on the back, buttocks, the head, while some had their homes burnt or knocked down or told never to return to their villagers by Zanu PF youths — pumped up with beer or marijuana.
Other defiant opposition villagers were taken to re-education camps and castigated for their treachery and perfidy while suffering long nights of physical abuse and indoctrination.
Under his electoral regime, rural voters faced a world where silence was the only option and chose to live in obedience, in silence, well aware any dissent would be crushed.
Msipha said chiefs have over the years been very pivotal in the political economy of rural areas as they act as instruments of both coercion and party organisation.
"You cannot separate chiefs from Zanu PF in most of the Mashonaland areas where they are also key elements of the party structure. With their loyalty bought by the token cars, Zanu PF is guaranteed of the next rural vote unless the opposition employs some sophisticated programmes to outflank Zanu PF on the rural economy front.
"Cars are only cementing what ED has done through command inputs and other programmes. Only an independent economic organisation in the rural areas can liberate the people from Zanu PF structures," said Msipha.
Analyst Maxwell Saungweme said the development demonstrates that Mnangagwa's presidency was a false dawn.
"Giving those cars is so insensitive at a juncture we have crisis in social services with sewage gushing out of taps in Harare and hospitals lacking essential drugs. This shows us that the military regime in Harare is interested not in public service delivery and democracy but strengthening its foothold on power," opined Saungweme.
"Buying chiefs cars and making them de-facto Zanu PF campaign agents is a major efficacious, tried and tested rigging strategy in Zanu PF's tool box of poll manipulation," he added.
Mnangagwa's spokesperson George Charamba has rejected charges that the handover of cars was "sickening vote buying", saying what was sickening was a chief who goes about in scorch-cart or on a bicycle.
"Traditional leaders have conditions of service, and those conditions must be commensurate with the dignity we attach to their office as traditional leaders," he told the Daily News.
"As a matter of fact, that condition went unmet for almost six or so years because of problems of finance in government. If you remember, it was the last act done by the former president, which the current president has implemented. It's not the first time chiefs are getting vehicles," Charamba said, warning the "unelectable" MDC against picking a fight over that issue and alienating chiefs by questioning why they should be driving.
This comes after Mnangagwa splurged a fortune on 52 brand new double cab cars for traditional leaders, in a move that has been roundly condemned as "sickening vote-buying" by Zanu PF ahead of the watershed polls - and not withstanding other more urgent needs.
Mnangagwa and his deputy, Constantino Chiwenga, handed over the cars in Gweru on Saturday after meeting with 286 traditional chiefs.
He said the rest of the cars were on their way.
Rights groups and the opposition allege that in return of the privileges, the chiefs are expected to render unconditional support for Mnangagwa and his lieutenants in Zanu PF and act as agents of the electoral authoritarian ruling regime in the do-or-die 2018 general polls.
Mnangagwa, who ascended to power last November in a military coup that toppled veteran ruler Robert Mugabe, faces a tough challenge in the presidential vote being held alongside parliamentary and municipal ballots around mid this year.
The main opposition MDC said traditional leaders were obliged to be non-political actors by the supreme law of the land.
"Of course, . . . Mnangagwa is smelling a humiliating defeat at the hands of the MDC in the forthcoming elections; thus, he is desperately trying to garner support from the country's traditional leaders to enable them to virtually coerce their subjects to vote for Zanu PF," MDC spokesperson Obert Gutu told the Daily News.
"However, this strategy will not work because the majority of the chiefs and other traditional leaders are very smart people. They don't want to be used as Zanu PF's political commissars.
"The time of the hand-over of the motor vehicles to chiefs is obviously meant to compromise them and make them willing tools of the Zanu PF regime. This will not work because the chiefs know that the Zanu PF regime, even under . . . Mugabe, was never genuinely interested in looking after their welfare."
Stephen Chan, a professor of world politics at the School of Oriental and African Studies at the University of London in the United Kingdom, said as far as he can see, Mnangagwa has continued a practice borrowed from the Mugabe era.
"I disagree with it but it is, unfortunately, a common political phenomenon in many parts of Africa," opined Chan.
Gladys Hlatywayo, a political analyst and civil rights campaigner, said it was sad that the Mnangagwa administration was demonstrating each day that it is not different from the previous regime.
"They continue to use the same tactics and strategies and, personally, I struggle to see the so-called ‘new dispensation'. It is a case of misplaced priorities given the state of the economy," she said.
Zimbabwe's economy is deep in the throes of a debilitating economic crisis, which has led to horrendous company closures and the consequent loss of hundreds of thousands of jobs.
Life has therefore become more and more unbearable for millions of long-suffering Zimbabweans, as the local economy continues to die amid a severe shortage of cash.
Hlatywayo said the timing of Mnangagwa's benevolence points to the motive.
"Like the previous administration, this administration seeks to use traditional leaders to mobilise on its behalf ahead of upcoming elections," she said.
Dewa Mavhinga, head of the Human Rights Watch Southern Africa, said there was no difference between Mnangagwa and Mugabe when it comes to Zanu PF's relationship with chiefs.
"The timing of the car gifts to chiefs ahead of elections could point to inducements for chiefs to support and campaign for Zanu PF in violation of the Constitution which requires chiefs to be strictly non-partisan. It points to misplaced priorities when hospitals lack basic medicines and equipment," he said.
Analyst Tamuka Charles Chirimambowa said each car can buy four tractors and with 230 cars, you have close to a 1 000 tractors that could have boosted farmers.
"The buying of cars is consumption economics and if he would have bought something like tractors, that's production economics," he said.
Analyst Xwayani Hope Msipha said the dishing out of cars to chiefs was a clear political move done by a party conscious of the need to seal the rural areas from the opposition.
Mugabe built a massive wall of fear for the rural people — who constitute 75 percent of the Zimbabwean voter bloc — maintaining control over the rural vote by directing ordinary voters to give their ballot-paper serial numbers to their village headmen, who would have marshalled the voters to the polling station and made them queue in a predetermined order, blatantly violating the sanctity of the vote.
Intimidated villagers willingly voted for Zanu PF, and those who disobeyed this instruction were ruthlessly punished — commanded to sprawl on the ground, sometimes naked, then clobbered on the back, buttocks, the head, while some had their homes burnt or knocked down or told never to return to their villagers by Zanu PF youths — pumped up with beer or marijuana.
Other defiant opposition villagers were taken to re-education camps and castigated for their treachery and perfidy while suffering long nights of physical abuse and indoctrination.
Under his electoral regime, rural voters faced a world where silence was the only option and chose to live in obedience, in silence, well aware any dissent would be crushed.
Msipha said chiefs have over the years been very pivotal in the political economy of rural areas as they act as instruments of both coercion and party organisation.
"You cannot separate chiefs from Zanu PF in most of the Mashonaland areas where they are also key elements of the party structure. With their loyalty bought by the token cars, Zanu PF is guaranteed of the next rural vote unless the opposition employs some sophisticated programmes to outflank Zanu PF on the rural economy front.
"Cars are only cementing what ED has done through command inputs and other programmes. Only an independent economic organisation in the rural areas can liberate the people from Zanu PF structures," said Msipha.
Analyst Maxwell Saungweme said the development demonstrates that Mnangagwa's presidency was a false dawn.
"Giving those cars is so insensitive at a juncture we have crisis in social services with sewage gushing out of taps in Harare and hospitals lacking essential drugs. This shows us that the military regime in Harare is interested not in public service delivery and democracy but strengthening its foothold on power," opined Saungweme.
"Buying chiefs cars and making them de-facto Zanu PF campaign agents is a major efficacious, tried and tested rigging strategy in Zanu PF's tool box of poll manipulation," he added.
Mnangagwa's spokesperson George Charamba has rejected charges that the handover of cars was "sickening vote buying", saying what was sickening was a chief who goes about in scorch-cart or on a bicycle.
"Traditional leaders have conditions of service, and those conditions must be commensurate with the dignity we attach to their office as traditional leaders," he told the Daily News.
"As a matter of fact, that condition went unmet for almost six or so years because of problems of finance in government. If you remember, it was the last act done by the former president, which the current president has implemented. It's not the first time chiefs are getting vehicles," Charamba said, warning the "unelectable" MDC against picking a fight over that issue and alienating chiefs by questioning why they should be driving.
Source - dailynews
