Latest News Editor's Choice


News / National

Why Mnangagwa fired Muguti

by Staff reporter
9 mins ago | 42 Views
PRESIDENT Emmerson Mnangagwa has removed Tafadzwa Muguti as Local Government and Public Works permanent secretary barely two months after appointing him, amid reports of clashes with senior Government officials and disagreements over his management style.

Muguti, who assumed the position following a September 11, 2026 reshuffle, has been replaced by Addmore Pazvakavambwa in a surprise administrative shake-up that has raised questions about policy continuity and tensions within the ministry.

According to The Standard, Muguti's removal followed disagreements with influential figures, including Local Government Minister Daniel Garwe, over his approach to administration, alleged corruption and the enforcement of Government directives.

Sources within the ministry claimed that Muguti had attempted to address suspected irregularities involving travel and subsistence allowances, bringing him into conflict with senior officials.

His departure comes shortly after six ministry officials, including chief director Khonzani Ncube, appeared in court facing fraud allegations involving duplicate travel and subsistence allowance claims.

The officials are accused of prejudicing the State of ZiG360,644 and local authorities of US$19,419.

The allegations have not been proven in court.

A ministry source claimed that one of the accused officials had influential political connections, raising speculation about whether Muguti's attempts to address alleged misconduct contributed to his removal.

However, no evidence has been publicly established linking the criminal proceedings directly to Mnangagwa's decision.

Other sources attributed Muguti's departure to his outspoken personality and confrontational leadership approach.

"He was too talkative and that does not go well within government circles. The system is always against people who talk too much," one source told the publication.

The reported tensions were compounded by Muguti's controversial directive restricting live media coverage of proceedings in traditional leaders' courts.

Presidential spokesperson George Charamba publicly criticised the directive, arguing that Muguti had exceeded his authority.

"The former PS was out of order!" Charamba wrote on X.

He maintained that traditional courts operated within the judicial system and that decisions restricting media access could only be made by the relevant judicial authorities.

"No government official can bar the media from covering court proceedings; only judicial officers in charge of those proceedings can," he said.

The public rebuke intensified scrutiny of Muguti's conduct shortly before his removal.

Harare Residents Trust executive director Precious Shumba said the relationship between Muguti and Garwe had appeared difficult from the outset.

"From the beginning, it was never going to work. Engineer Tafadzwa Muguti and Daniel Garwe have similar personalities and have no prospects of successfully executing government programmes," Shumba said.

He interpreted the reshuffle as an indication that Mnangagwa had chosen to retain the political leadership of the ministry while replacing its senior administrative official.

Shumba also questioned the absence of an official explanation for Muguti's departure, particularly given the number of significant directives issued during his brief tenure.

Among these were restrictions on informal trading, measures against illegal land sales and instructions to local authorities concerning unpaid Government water bills.

Muguti initially took a firm position on vending activities before announcing that trading in central business districts would be permitted between 6am and 6pm across the country's 92 local authorities.

He also directed councils to disconnect water supplies to Government departments that failed to settle outstanding accounts and warned of possible arrests involving illegal land transactions.

Political analyst Reason Wafawarova said the abrupt reversal of Muguti's appointment raised broader questions about the Government's selection and assessment of senior officials.

"The president must be able to remove an official who is incompetent, insubordinate or unable to implement government policy," Wafawarova said.

"But when a senior appointment is reversed after only eight weeks, it also raises questions about the quality of the original vetting process."

He questioned what circumstances could have emerged during Muguti's short tenure that had not been considered before his appointment.

Wafawarova said the former permanent secretary's assertive leadership style and history of controversial enforcement measures were already well documented.

He noted that Muguti's brief tenure had become associated with disputes involving informal traders, housing demolitions, disaster-relief organisations and traditional courts.

The analyst also referred to Garwe's public intervention shortly before Muguti's departure, when the minister distanced central Government from certain demolitions and called for them to stop.

"That timing invites questions, but it does not by itself prove the reason for Muguti's departure," Wafawarova cautioned.

He warned that frequent changes in senior Government positions, particularly without clear explanations, could undermine institutional stability and accountability.

Wafawarova cited recent changes in the leadership of the Central Intelligence Organisation and other State institutions as examples of administrative turnover requiring greater public transparency.

"Constant chopping and changing in critical institutions can weaken policy continuity, blur accountability and encourage senior officials to govern according to what they imagine the President currently wants rather than through published policy," he said.

He challenged incoming permanent secretary Pazvakavambwa to clarify the status of the Government's settlement regularisation programme, particularly for communities facing possible demolitions.

Wafawarova said residents needed certainty about which settlements qualified for regularisation, the validity of previously issued documents and the status of outstanding demolition orders.

"If the programme stalls because one permanent secretary has been removed, then it was never a policy. It was a personality," he said.

Muguti's career has been characterised by forceful interventions in local governance, particularly concerning illegal settlements, wetlands protection and alleged land-related irregularities.

In May 2026, he halted a proposed housing development at Monavale Vlei, arguing that the protected wetland could not be developed without the necessary Government and parliamentary approvals.

He had previously ordered enforcement operations against illegal structures on wetlands around Harare, including a 45-day demolition campaign announced in November 2022.

His threats to demolish properties in Arlington Estates also attracted controversy, with critics questioning the legality of some directives.

Supporters of his approach, however, credited him with confronting illegal land development and attempting to enforce environmental and planning regulations.

The latest reshuffle leaves Pazvakavambwa responsible for overseeing several contentious programmes, including urban renewal, informal trading regulations and settlement regularisation.

Garwe could not be reached for comment, according to The Standard, while the Government had not publicly explained the reasons for Muguti's removal.

The absence of an official explanation has left competing accounts of the dismissal unresolved, with allegations of internal disagreements, administrative disputes and political considerations remaining unconfirmed.

Source - The Standard
Join the discussion
Loading comments…

Get the Daily Digest