News / National
Mugabe's plane movements used as barometer for his health
07 Sep 2016 at 10:14hrs | Views
President Robert Mugabe arriving home in Harare, Zimbabwe, on Saturday after a trip to the Middle East. Credit Philimon Bulawayo/Reuters
It is an indirect clue at best, but it is often all they can get: Many Zimbabweans have taken to divining the state of their increasingly frail 92-year-old leader's health from the movements of his presidential plane.
On Saturday morning, anyone with a smartphone could see that Air Zimbabwe Flight 1, as the plane is known, was hugging Africa's eastern coast on its way home to Harare, the capital, after four days in Dubai. The flight designation, UM1, meant that President Robert Mugabe, the world's oldest head of state, was on board.
Mr. Mugabe's trip to the Middle East had been made suddenly, with no explanation from the secretive Zimbabwean government, fueling rumors that the president was deathly ill and desperately seeking medical treatment overseas.
The main political opposition helped feed those rumors, with one of its leaders posting online, in a tone of great authority, that Mr. Mugabe had suffered a stroke and that it was unlikely "he can come back from this."
But ordinary Zimbabweans and journalists were left with hardly any verifiable facts, other than what flight tracking apps could tell them. And it was not the first time.
In March, when Mr. Mugabe was traveling in Asia, he canceled a visit to India at the last minute, and the government refused to reveal his whereabouts. The apps showed that his plane was in Singapore, one of the places where he has received medical treatment in recent years. (The government said he had cataract surgery there and was otherwise healthy, but a 2008 American diplomatic cable released by WikiLeaks said he had been treated in Singapore for prostate cancer.)
The president's health has been an all-consuming topic this year for Zimbabweans of all classes, as the effects of age and possible illness have become harder for Mr. Mugabe to hide. Many Zimbabweans, who have known only one leader since gaining independence 36 years ago, are bracing for the future with the same trepidation that many Chinese felt near the end of Mao Zedong's long rule, or that the Congolese did with Mobutu Sese Seko. They speak about "when the old man goes" or "when nature takes its course."
The uncertainty of a post-Mugabe political order compounds the anxieties. The political class is engulfed in a ferocious fight over succession, and it is far from clear where the security forces, the traditional guarantors of Mr. Mugabe's power, will stand.
In the capital, politicians and diplomats report that Mr. Mugabe has slowed down considerably in the past year. He works only a few hours a day and says little in meetings. Several times, he has been caught on video stumbling or falling asleep at public events.
Like most wealthy Zimbabweans, Mr. Mugabe goes abroad for better medical care than he can get at home. That narrows the circle of Zimbabweans who are truly informed about his health — and it means that every time he flies, especially on extended or unannounced trips outside Africa, the rumors fly as well, often claiming that he has died or is at death's door.
"There will never be a thing called a vacuum, so if the officials are not giving information, rumors will fill the vacuum," said Tendai Biti, the president of an opposition party, the People's Democratic Party. "The feelings of uncertainty are a byproduct of a very unstable environment created by the president himself."
"But this is not unique to Zimbabwe," added Mr. Biti, who served as finance minister in a coalition government from 2009 to 2013. "Mobutu used to die so many times. In Uganda, Idi Amin used to die so many times. In China, Chairman Mao used to die so many times. In Russia, how many times did Brezhnev used to die?"
This time, the speculation about Mr. Mugabe seemed to have more foundation than usual. He had been scheduled to go to Ghana in mid-August to receive a lifetime achievement award from the Millennium Excellence Foundation for helping to liberate Zimbabwe, but canceled the trip at the last minute.
When he resurfaced several days later at an agricultural show, his appearance merely fanned the flames. He seemed to stumble at one point and was apparently wearing slippers rather than shoes with his suit.
Mr. Mugabe appeared to bounce back, flying to Kenya on Aug. 26 for a conference, followed by a meeting in Swaziland. After that, however, UM1's movements began raising alarms in some circles. The plane left Swaziland a day before the conference ended, spent three hours in Harare and then took off again for Dubai, arriving on the morning of Aug. 31.
Days of silence ensued. The government said only that Mr. Mugabe was in the Middle East on official business. The Sept. 1 headline on the independent newspaper NewsDay read, "Mystery Over Mugabe Trip."
"Each time you people don't know the purpose of the president's visit, there is always a default explanation that he is ill," George Charamba, Mr. Mugabe's spokesman, was quoted in the article as saying.
Eddie Cross, a lawmaker with the main opposition party, Movement for Democratic Change, wrote on his blog the next day, "We hear that the Old Man had a stroke." He added, "It would have been so much more dignified if he had recognized that his ‘sell by' date had arrived and he had retired and handed over to a chosen successor."
UM1 took off again after midnight on Saturday, and by 6 a.m. the tracking apps had it over the waters between Mozambique and Madagascar, headed southwest. Journalists and officials began to gather at Harare's airport, where the sun shone in a clear sky on a fine spring morning.
When the plane landed at 7:58, reporters for the state news media were ushered onto the tarmac.
"Yes, it's true," Mr. Mugabe told them cheerfully. "I was dead, and I resurrected, as I always do."
He said he had gone to Dubai to check up on his elder son, Robert Jr., an architecture student who regularly posts photos of himself partying with beautiful women.
Speculation immediately turned to whether Mr. Mugabe's allies had churned up false rumors of his death to discredit the independent news media and the political opposition. Zimbabwe's central intelligence organization has a history of spreading disinformation.
Mr. Cross, the opposition lawmaker, said by phone that he had based his blog post on information from intelligence officials, members of the governing ZANU-PF party, South African intelligence officials and a minister.
Conjuring a scene from the macabre comedy "Weekend at Bernie's," Mr. Cross argued that Mr. Mugabe's allies were propping up a dying president to maintain their hold on power. "You talk about the living dead," he said. "It's sad, actually."
At the airport, a reporter asked Mr. Mugabe whether he was a ghost. "Once I get back to my country," he replied, "I am real."
On Saturday morning, anyone with a smartphone could see that Air Zimbabwe Flight 1, as the plane is known, was hugging Africa's eastern coast on its way home to Harare, the capital, after four days in Dubai. The flight designation, UM1, meant that President Robert Mugabe, the world's oldest head of state, was on board.
Mr. Mugabe's trip to the Middle East had been made suddenly, with no explanation from the secretive Zimbabwean government, fueling rumors that the president was deathly ill and desperately seeking medical treatment overseas.
The main political opposition helped feed those rumors, with one of its leaders posting online, in a tone of great authority, that Mr. Mugabe had suffered a stroke and that it was unlikely "he can come back from this."
But ordinary Zimbabweans and journalists were left with hardly any verifiable facts, other than what flight tracking apps could tell them. And it was not the first time.
In March, when Mr. Mugabe was traveling in Asia, he canceled a visit to India at the last minute, and the government refused to reveal his whereabouts. The apps showed that his plane was in Singapore, one of the places where he has received medical treatment in recent years. (The government said he had cataract surgery there and was otherwise healthy, but a 2008 American diplomatic cable released by WikiLeaks said he had been treated in Singapore for prostate cancer.)
The president's health has been an all-consuming topic this year for Zimbabweans of all classes, as the effects of age and possible illness have become harder for Mr. Mugabe to hide. Many Zimbabweans, who have known only one leader since gaining independence 36 years ago, are bracing for the future with the same trepidation that many Chinese felt near the end of Mao Zedong's long rule, or that the Congolese did with Mobutu Sese Seko. They speak about "when the old man goes" or "when nature takes its course."
The uncertainty of a post-Mugabe political order compounds the anxieties. The political class is engulfed in a ferocious fight over succession, and it is far from clear where the security forces, the traditional guarantors of Mr. Mugabe's power, will stand.
In the capital, politicians and diplomats report that Mr. Mugabe has slowed down considerably in the past year. He works only a few hours a day and says little in meetings. Several times, he has been caught on video stumbling or falling asleep at public events.
Like most wealthy Zimbabweans, Mr. Mugabe goes abroad for better medical care than he can get at home. That narrows the circle of Zimbabweans who are truly informed about his health — and it means that every time he flies, especially on extended or unannounced trips outside Africa, the rumors fly as well, often claiming that he has died or is at death's door.
"There will never be a thing called a vacuum, so if the officials are not giving information, rumors will fill the vacuum," said Tendai Biti, the president of an opposition party, the People's Democratic Party. "The feelings of uncertainty are a byproduct of a very unstable environment created by the president himself."
"But this is not unique to Zimbabwe," added Mr. Biti, who served as finance minister in a coalition government from 2009 to 2013. "Mobutu used to die so many times. In Uganda, Idi Amin used to die so many times. In China, Chairman Mao used to die so many times. In Russia, how many times did Brezhnev used to die?"
This time, the speculation about Mr. Mugabe seemed to have more foundation than usual. He had been scheduled to go to Ghana in mid-August to receive a lifetime achievement award from the Millennium Excellence Foundation for helping to liberate Zimbabwe, but canceled the trip at the last minute.
When he resurfaced several days later at an agricultural show, his appearance merely fanned the flames. He seemed to stumble at one point and was apparently wearing slippers rather than shoes with his suit.
Mr. Mugabe appeared to bounce back, flying to Kenya on Aug. 26 for a conference, followed by a meeting in Swaziland. After that, however, UM1's movements began raising alarms in some circles. The plane left Swaziland a day before the conference ended, spent three hours in Harare and then took off again for Dubai, arriving on the morning of Aug. 31.
Days of silence ensued. The government said only that Mr. Mugabe was in the Middle East on official business. The Sept. 1 headline on the independent newspaper NewsDay read, "Mystery Over Mugabe Trip."
"Each time you people don't know the purpose of the president's visit, there is always a default explanation that he is ill," George Charamba, Mr. Mugabe's spokesman, was quoted in the article as saying.
Eddie Cross, a lawmaker with the main opposition party, Movement for Democratic Change, wrote on his blog the next day, "We hear that the Old Man had a stroke." He added, "It would have been so much more dignified if he had recognized that his ‘sell by' date had arrived and he had retired and handed over to a chosen successor."
UM1 took off again after midnight on Saturday, and by 6 a.m. the tracking apps had it over the waters between Mozambique and Madagascar, headed southwest. Journalists and officials began to gather at Harare's airport, where the sun shone in a clear sky on a fine spring morning.
When the plane landed at 7:58, reporters for the state news media were ushered onto the tarmac.
"Yes, it's true," Mr. Mugabe told them cheerfully. "I was dead, and I resurrected, as I always do."
He said he had gone to Dubai to check up on his elder son, Robert Jr., an architecture student who regularly posts photos of himself partying with beautiful women.
Speculation immediately turned to whether Mr. Mugabe's allies had churned up false rumors of his death to discredit the independent news media and the political opposition. Zimbabwe's central intelligence organization has a history of spreading disinformation.
Mr. Cross, the opposition lawmaker, said by phone that he had based his blog post on information from intelligence officials, members of the governing ZANU-PF party, South African intelligence officials and a minister.
Conjuring a scene from the macabre comedy "Weekend at Bernie's," Mr. Cross argued that Mr. Mugabe's allies were propping up a dying president to maintain their hold on power. "You talk about the living dead," he said. "It's sad, actually."
At the airport, a reporter asked Mr. Mugabe whether he was a ghost. "Once I get back to my country," he replied, "I am real."
Source - New York Times
