2013 voters' roll has no place in the 2018 election

Election Resource Centre a civil rights watchdog has warned that the 2013 voters' roll has no place in the 2018 election.

The centre said as Zimbabwe heads towards the 2018 elections which are now about a year away, questions on the 2013 voters' roll can no longer be ignored on the basis of two potential realities. "Firstly, the Electoral Act, as it currently stands, does not definitively establish a fresh registration process which will ultimately vanquish the 2013 voters' roll and thus barring voting on the basis of being registered on the old voters' roll," said the centre.

"Section 36A of the Electoral Act needs to be amended to effectively bring forth a fresh registration process without leaving a back door open for old registrants who may fail to register through the proposed biometric process, to claim their vote on the basis of the old roll. While the recently gazetted Statutory Instrument 85 (S.I. 85) of 2017, which outlined voter registration regulations, obligates the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) Chief Elections Officer to authenticate or certify the subsequent voters' roll following closure of the register for a given electoral event, the regulations are not explicit as to what happens with the pre-existing 2013 voters' roll."

The organisation said the new voter registration regulations fails to address growing fears on possible use of the 2013 voters' roll, by omitting the fate of the pre-existing 2013 voters' roll.

"This could have clarified provisions of Section 36A of the Electoral Act which requires ZEC to take a position about the pre-existing voters' roll. Secondly the Election Resource Centre (ERC) has already witnessed ZEC conduct by-elections on the basis of a main voters' roll which was being compiled through mobile voter registration and a supplementary voters' roll which is the 2013 roll less people who will have registered afresh," said the centre.

"Such a precedence is dangerous come 2018 as, without strengthening the legal framework of our elections, we may have two rolls applying for the polls. Sadly, the use of two voters' rolls alone, make our elections difficult to verify as is prescribed by the Constitution of Zimbabwe. Furthermore, any invitation and acceptance of use of a voters' roll that has been kept a secret over the last four years in the 2018 elections would be akin to crucifying the credibility of that election."

The centre said the 2013 voters' roll must therefore not be seen anywhere near our future elections.

"One narrative that has prompted the initiative to lay bare the dangers of non-exhaustively burying the 2013 voters' roll is the narrative of the possibility of an early election. The state media has proposed, through statements attributed to a senior Zimbabwe African National Union Patriotic Front (ZANU PF) official, that there is scope for the President to call for an early election," said the centre.

"While Zimbabwe's next harmonised elections are constitutionally scheduled for between end of July and end of August 2018, it is conceivable that a ruling party, enjoying a Parliamentary majority, could entertain the option of stampeding the nation into an early poll, if doing so strategically gives the incumbent an edge over opponents."

"Considering the capacity of the ruling party to execute the "threat" of an early election, it would make sense to attempt to influence other variables associated with such a scenario such as the voters' roll which will be used, the rules of the election and the state of the election administrative infrastructure. The effort to scuttle attempts at a stampeded election must be accompanied by a very loud demand for the timely and necessary reforms to guarantee credibility of electoral processes," the centre added.

The centre said the consequences of failing to cremate the 2013 voters' roll ahead of the 2018 election include the fact that stakeholders would have to content with a document that has been kept away from public scrutiny for years.

"Using such a document either as a primary document or even a secondary one would dent the credibility of the 2018 election. Public confidence that the election would not be predetermined would be greatly undermined. Another consequence that would accrue if the 2013 voters' roll was to resurrect ahead of 2018 is that the verifiability of the election results would be difficult to sustain. Zimbabwe's previous voters' rolls have contained some discrepancies which cannot be wished away through some ceremonial cleansing process. The demon associated with the old voters' roll can only be cast by total annihilation of any trace that the roll ever existed," the organisation said.

"While limited time remains to put in place credible processes with credible results, what is crucial is how effectively the limited time left is efficiently used. An emphasis of advocacy for a strengthened legal framework will, if successful, form the foundation for sound election processes. Doing all else right while the foundation of our elections remains weak will only result in a total collapse of that which is being built."

The ERC called upon election authorities to direct effort towards ensuring a strengthened ZEC that has a relationship with the public, and administers electoral processes independently.

"The environment in which electoral processes are conducted is the last frontier that must remain free from violence and intimidation. The clarion call going forward must thus be that a credible voter registration process to replace the 2013 voters' roll is a must and any call for an early election must be informed by the finalisation of a clean voters' roll that has been availed to stakeholders in time for independent audits of it to be concluded and final copies made public," the organisation said.