News / National
Legal fight against Grace Mugabe immunity begins
26 Aug 2017 at 11:04hrs | Views
South African opposition party Democratic Alliance (DA) yesterday launched a Constitutional Court (Con-Court) battle seeking a declaration that the decision by the minister of International Relations and Cooperation Maite Nkoana-Mashabane to grant diplomatic immunity to Zimbabwe First Lady Grace Mugabe be declared unconstitutional and invalid.
With passions inflamed by the decision to let Grace leave the neighbouring country after it was claimed she whipped 20-year-old model Gabriella Engels with an electrical cord in a luxury hotel room in Johannesburg, the DA want the diplomatic immunity set aside arguing it was wholly without legal merit.
This comes as advocacy group AfriForum, which is giving legal backing to Engels, and is working on the case with Gerrie Nel - the prosecutor who secured a murder conviction against Oscar Pistorius - also started taking legal action over the government's decision to grant her diplomatic immunity on Wednesday.
The DA filed papers in the Con-Court yesterday requesting direct access to the apex court, citing Nkoana-Mashabane, SA President Jacob Zuma, Engels and national director of public prosecutions as respondents.
The DA argued in its urgent application that the decision by Nkoana-Mashabane, in granting immunity, was "hasty, embarrassing and above all illegal and unconstitutional".
"It is frankly unconscionable that after the scathing ruling by the Constitutional Court in the Al Bashir matter that the ANC-led government would once again let a high-profile person escape justice in South Africa," the court papers say.
The International Criminal Court last month rebuked South Africa for not arresting Sudan's president on a genocide warrant when he visited Johannesburg in 2015, but declined to refer Pretoria to the United Nations for possible censure over the lapse.
The DA, led by Musi Maimane, said it was clear that Grace was granted immunity simply to shield her from being tried in a court of law for her assault on Engels and two others on August 13.
It said in its Con-Court papers that condoning such behaviour, as the granting of immunity did, cannot possibly be in the interests of South Africa.
"There is therefore no legal basis for such a decision," the court papers said.
The DA said Grace is not a member of the Zimbabwean government and she was in South Africa on personal business.
"There is nothing in either South African or international law which renders her deserving of diplomatic immunity," it argued, adding the incident is yet another example of how the ANC-led government is intent on protecting the elite of Africa by abusing its statutory powers at the expense of justice for ordinary South Africans.
With passions inflamed by the decision to let Grace leave the neighbouring country after it was claimed she whipped 20-year-old model Gabriella Engels with an electrical cord in a luxury hotel room in Johannesburg, the DA want the diplomatic immunity set aside arguing it was wholly without legal merit.
This comes as advocacy group AfriForum, which is giving legal backing to Engels, and is working on the case with Gerrie Nel - the prosecutor who secured a murder conviction against Oscar Pistorius - also started taking legal action over the government's decision to grant her diplomatic immunity on Wednesday.
The DA filed papers in the Con-Court yesterday requesting direct access to the apex court, citing Nkoana-Mashabane, SA President Jacob Zuma, Engels and national director of public prosecutions as respondents.
The DA argued in its urgent application that the decision by Nkoana-Mashabane, in granting immunity, was "hasty, embarrassing and above all illegal and unconstitutional".
"It is frankly unconscionable that after the scathing ruling by the Constitutional Court in the Al Bashir matter that the ANC-led government would once again let a high-profile person escape justice in South Africa," the court papers say.
The DA, led by Musi Maimane, said it was clear that Grace was granted immunity simply to shield her from being tried in a court of law for her assault on Engels and two others on August 13.
It said in its Con-Court papers that condoning such behaviour, as the granting of immunity did, cannot possibly be in the interests of South Africa.
"There is therefore no legal basis for such a decision," the court papers said.
The DA said Grace is not a member of the Zimbabwean government and she was in South Africa on personal business.
"There is nothing in either South African or international law which renders her deserving of diplomatic immunity," it argued, adding the incident is yet another example of how the ANC-led government is intent on protecting the elite of Africa by abusing its statutory powers at the expense of justice for ordinary South Africans.
Source - dailynews
