News / National
Advocate Jeremy Gauntlett quits amid boy sex abuse allegations
3 hrs ago | Views
Zimbabwean-born legal luminary Advocate Jeremy Gauntlett, whose illustrious career spanned South Africa, Zimbabwe, and the United Kingdom, has retired from the bar following allegations of historic sexual abuse. Gauntlett, born in Salisbury (now Harare), Rhodesia, in 1950, had built a reputation as one of the most celebrated legal minds of his time. However, his legacy has been overshadowed by these serious allegations, marking a dramatic fall from grace.
The controversy erupted after Dr. Hylton White, a senior lecturer at the University of the Witwatersrand, accused Gauntlett of sexually abusing him during his teenage years. The revelations came to light after White publicly criticized Gauntlett's appointment to an Anglican Church panel investigating the abuse perpetrated by the late British barrister John Smyth.
Smyth, notorious for abusing at least 85 boys across multiple countries, including Zimbabwe, was the subject of scrutiny by the church. Gauntlett had been appointed alongside Dr. Mamphela Ramphele and retired judge Ian Farlam to investigate how the Anglican Church in South Africa handled Smyth's abuses.
White alleged that Gauntlett, who had previously positioned himself as a mentor and ally, had sexually exploited him under the guise of intellectual and emotional support. White described incidents that ranged from inappropriate physical contact to sexual abuse, painting a harrowing picture of betrayal and manipulation.
White recounted how Gauntlett took advantage of their mentor-mentee relationship, saying, "What he did behind me I can't say." He detailed further encounters at Gauntlett's home in Constantia, at hotels, and even on the University of Cape Town campus, alleging a pattern of grooming and abuse. White's accusations also highlighted the power imbalance that left him vulnerable, compounded by Gauntlett's esteemed position in society.
After White wrote to the Anglican Church demanding Gauntlett's removal from the panel, his concerns were initially ignored. When no action was taken, White went public with his allegations, forcing Gauntlett to resign from the church panel in November 2024.
The General Council of the Bar (GCB) of South Africa confirmed that the allegations had been referred to the Cape Bar and Johannesburg Society of Advocates for investigation. In a statement, the GCB acknowledged the gravity of the accusations, noting their impact on public trust in the legal profession.
As public scrutiny intensified, Gauntlett, a dual South African and British citizen, announced his retirement from law practice, effectively ending a storied career that once saw him as a defender of liberation fighters and a champion of justice.
Jeremy Gauntlett's career was one of remarkable achievements, but these allegations have cast a long shadow over his legacy. His retirement under such ignominious circumstances marks the end of a career that once stood as a beacon of legal excellence but now serves as a cautionary tale of power, betrayal, and accountability.
The scandal has also reignited broader discussions about institutional responses to sexual abuse allegations, particularly within religious and legal circles. As investigations continue, the legal community and the Anglican Church face mounting pressure to ensure transparency and justice for victims.
The controversy erupted after Dr. Hylton White, a senior lecturer at the University of the Witwatersrand, accused Gauntlett of sexually abusing him during his teenage years. The revelations came to light after White publicly criticized Gauntlett's appointment to an Anglican Church panel investigating the abuse perpetrated by the late British barrister John Smyth.
Smyth, notorious for abusing at least 85 boys across multiple countries, including Zimbabwe, was the subject of scrutiny by the church. Gauntlett had been appointed alongside Dr. Mamphela Ramphele and retired judge Ian Farlam to investigate how the Anglican Church in South Africa handled Smyth's abuses.
White alleged that Gauntlett, who had previously positioned himself as a mentor and ally, had sexually exploited him under the guise of intellectual and emotional support. White described incidents that ranged from inappropriate physical contact to sexual abuse, painting a harrowing picture of betrayal and manipulation.
White recounted how Gauntlett took advantage of their mentor-mentee relationship, saying, "What he did behind me I can't say." He detailed further encounters at Gauntlett's home in Constantia, at hotels, and even on the University of Cape Town campus, alleging a pattern of grooming and abuse. White's accusations also highlighted the power imbalance that left him vulnerable, compounded by Gauntlett's esteemed position in society.
The General Council of the Bar (GCB) of South Africa confirmed that the allegations had been referred to the Cape Bar and Johannesburg Society of Advocates for investigation. In a statement, the GCB acknowledged the gravity of the accusations, noting their impact on public trust in the legal profession.
As public scrutiny intensified, Gauntlett, a dual South African and British citizen, announced his retirement from law practice, effectively ending a storied career that once saw him as a defender of liberation fighters and a champion of justice.
Jeremy Gauntlett's career was one of remarkable achievements, but these allegations have cast a long shadow over his legacy. His retirement under such ignominious circumstances marks the end of a career that once stood as a beacon of legal excellence but now serves as a cautionary tale of power, betrayal, and accountability.
The scandal has also reignited broader discussions about institutional responses to sexual abuse allegations, particularly within religious and legal circles. As investigations continue, the legal community and the Anglican Church face mounting pressure to ensure transparency and justice for victims.
Source - online
