Latest News Editor's Choice


News / National

Zanu PF activism by prison officer is unconstitutional

by Staff reporter
15 mins ago | 30 Views
THE High Court has ruled that a serving Zimbabwe Prisons and Correctional Service (ZPCS) officer cannot simultaneously hold a leadership position in ZANU PF, declaring such political involvement unconstitutional and condemning prison authorities for failing to investigate allegations of partisan conduct.

Justice Priscilla Munangati-Manongwa delivered the ruling in a case involving former prison officer Caroline Majongo, who was accused of serving as ZANU PF Mashonaland East Women's League provincial deputy secretary while employed by the correctional service.

The court also found that ZPCS Commissioner-General Moses Chihobvu and the Prisons and Correctional Service Commission had failed to discharge their constitutional responsibilities after receiving a formal complaint about Majongo's political activities.

The judgment reinforces constitutional provisions requiring members of Zimbabwe's security services to remain politically neutral and refrain from active participation in partisan politics.

Justice Munangati-Manongwa said prison authorities had a constitutional duty to investigate credible allegations of misconduct rather than disregard them.

"It is therefore not a discretionary power which the respondents could simply elect not to exercise once a credible allegation of non-compliance had been brought to their attention," she ruled.

"It is clear that upon receiving the complaint no investigation was conducted regarding the allegations."

The case arose after Takudzwanashe Edward Mudzuri approached the High Court, accusing prison authorities of failing to enforce constitutional safeguards against political involvement by security personnel.

Mudzuri had written to the authorities on July 5, requesting an investigation into Majongo's alleged participation in ZANU PF activities.

His complaint was supported by correspondence from the ruling party's Mashonaland East provincial leadership requesting that Majongo be released from her official duties to participate in political mobilisation ahead of the 2023 harmonised elections.

The letters identified Majongo as a deputy provincial secretary in the ZANU PF Women's League.

However, Mudzuri received no response, and no investigation or disciplinary proceedings were initiated.

He subsequently sought constitutional relief from the High Court.

During the proceedings, the prison authorities challenged the reliability of the correspondence, arguing that its authenticity had not been independently verified.

Justice Munangati-Manongwa rejected that argument, finding that the documents provided sufficient grounds for an investigation.

"The letters bear ZANU PF letterheads; they are duly stamped, and the authors thereof are identified by name and office," she said.

The judge also noted that Majongo had not submitted an affidavit denying that she held the political position attributed to her.

"Equally, there is no affidavit from the fourth respondent denying that she held the political office attributed to her. The absence of a factual denial leaves the documentary evidence unanswered and substantially unchallenged."

The court concluded that the correspondence established a prima facie breach of Section 208(3) of the Constitution.

That provision prohibits serving members of the security services from being active members or office-bearers of political parties.

"The evidence establishes a prima facie breach," Justice Munangati-Manongwa ruled.

The judge emphasised that the prohibition was designed to protect the independence and professionalism of State security institutions.

"The Constitution demands political neutrality from the security services to preserve public confidence, professionalism and equal protection under the law," she said.

The Commissioner-General and other respondents opposed Mudzuri's application on several grounds.

They argued that he lacked the legal standing to bring the case, had failed to exhaust available remedies under the Administrative Justice Act and had not properly served Majongo with court papers.

They further submitted that the matter had become academic because Majongo had left the prison service on July 30, 2024.

However, Justice Munangati-Manongwa dismissed the preliminary objections.

She held that Section 85 of the Constitution permitted Mudzuri to approach the court in the public interest to enforce constitutional rights and obligations.

The judge also rejected the argument that Majongo's departure from the correctional service rendered the dispute irrelevant.

Although disciplinary proceedings against her could no longer be pursued through the service, the court found that the constitutional questions surrounding her conduct and the authorities' failure to investigate remained important.

Justice Munangati-Manongwa stressed that the central issue was not whether prison authorities should have dismissed Majongo, but whether they had fulfilled their duty to investigate allegations of constitutional misconduct.

"The respondents focused on disputing the authenticity of the letters. Yet the constitutional complaint is not that the respondents failed to dismiss the fourth respondent but rather that they altogether failed to investigate the complaint or allegations of constitutional misconduct," she said.

"It is this inaction which is inconsistent with the constitutional mandate imposed by s 231(1)(d) which is cause for complaint."

Section 231(1)(d) requires the Prisons and Correctional Service Commission to ensure that members of the service comply with the political neutrality obligations prescribed under Section 208.

The judge found that the failure to investigate constituted a constitutional violation in its own right.

Justice Munangati-Manongwa warned that public institutions risk undermining confidence in constitutional governance when they fail to enforce obligations imposed upon them by the Constitution.

"Any failure to fulfil these obligations undermines public confidence in their commitment to constitutional governance and casts a bad light upon them," she said.

The High Court ultimately declared Majongo's participation in partisan political activities while serving as a prison officer unconstitutional.

It also ruled that the failure by the Commissioner-General and the Prisons and Correctional Service Commission to ensure compliance with Section 208 was unconstitutional.

The court ordered the Commissioner-General, the chairperson of the Prisons and Correctional Service Commission and Majongo to pay Mudzuri's legal costs jointly and severally, meaning payment by one would discharge the others' liability for those costs.

The judgment establishes that prison authorities cannot avoid their constitutional responsibilities simply by questioning allegations without investigating them.

It also underscores that the obligation of political neutrality applies to serving security personnel regardless of the political party involved.

The ruling serves as a reminder that members of Zimbabwe's security services are constitutionally prohibited from holding partisan political office while in active service, and that the institutions responsible for supervising them must take credible allegations of violations seriously.

Source - NewZimbabwe
More on: #ZPSC, #Court, #Activism
Join the discussion
Loading comments…

Get the Daily Digest