News / National
South Africa court capture: Malema forces Zille to run to Cape Town court
13 mins ago |
44 Views
ECONOMIC Freedom Fighters (EFF) leader Julius Malema has accused Democratic Alliance (DA) Johannesburg mayoral candidate Helen Zille of attempting to shift their escalating defamation dispute from Johannesburg to Cape Town, questioning why she appears determined to have the matter heard in the Western Cape.
The political confrontation follows explosive allegations made by Zille during a television interview, in which she accused Malema of exerting improper influence over the City of Johannesburg during former mayor Herman Mashaba's administration.
Malema, who is threatening a R1 million defamation lawsuit, insists that the dispute should be heard in Johannesburg, where he says the alleged defamatory statements were made and where the events discussed took place.
On Monday, Malema published a copy of Zille's Notice of Opposition on social media platform X, drawing attention to the document's reference to the Western Cape Division of the High Court in Cape Town.
The document identifies Malema as the first applicant, the EFF as the second applicant and Zille as the respondent.
Malema interpreted the filing as an attempt to move the legal battle away from Johannesburg.
"We are suing her in Johannesburg, but she insists that the case be heard in Cape Town. What does she know about that court that gives her such confidence?" Malema wrote.
He questioned why Zille, who is seeking to become Johannesburg's mayor, would prefer proceedings in Cape Town when the dispute concerns the governance of Johannesburg.
"She made these nonsensical remarks here in Johannesburg about Johannesburg, and she is a mayoral candidate here. Yet she wants to run to the Cape Town High Court," he said.
"One day, the truth will come out. We will fight this case where the alleged conduct took place."
The Notice of Opposition has intensified the disagreement, although the document alone does not establish that a court has ordered the matter transferred or determined which division has jurisdiction.
The dispute began following Zille's appearance on eNCA on Sunday, November 8, when she made a series of allegations concerning Malema's alleged influence over Johannesburg's municipal administration between 2016 and 2019.
During the interview, Zille characterised Mashaba, who served as Johannesburg mayor during that period, as effectively operating as "the EFF mayor" to maintain his position.
She alleged that Mashaba had allowed Malema to dictate important municipal decisions and influence appointments and contracts within the city.
Among the allegations was a claim that Malema had effectively captured City Power, Johannesburg's municipal electricity utility.
Zille also alleged that Malema influenced a municipal fleet tender to benefit companies she described as his fronts.
She further claimed that Malema had directed the appointment of Shadrack Sibiya as head of Johannesburg's anti-corruption unit.
The allegations have not been established in court, and Malema has rejected them as defamatory.
Malema Demands Apology and Retraction
Following the interview, Malema instructed his lawyers, England Slabbert Attorneys, to issue a formal letter of demand to Zille.
The letter, dated November 9, accused Zille of making malicious and unfounded allegations and presenting them as established facts.
Malema's legal representatives argued that the statements were calculated to damage his reputation and political standing.
They demanded that Zille withdraw the allegations in full, issue a public apology and provide a written undertaking that she would not repeat them.
Zille was given until the close of business on November 11 to comply.
However, the former DA federal leader refused to withdraw her statements.
Her lawyers, Minde Schapiro & Smith Inc., responded with a brief but uncompromising rejection of Malema's demands.
"We have received your letter dated 9th November 2026. The answer to all your client's demands is: No. See you in court."
The response signalled Zille's willingness to defend her remarks through legal proceedings rather than issue the apology sought by Malema.
The dispute has now expanded beyond the substance of Zille's allegations to include disagreement over where the legal proceedings should take place.
Malema maintains that Johannesburg is the appropriate venue because the remarks concerned the city's administration and were allegedly made there.
He also argues that Zille's status as the DA's Johannesburg mayoral candidate makes her preference for Cape Town particularly questionable.
However, the legal question of jurisdiction would ultimately depend on the applicable court rules, the parties' connections to the relevant jurisdictions and the circumstances surrounding the proceedings.
The available information does not establish Zille's legal reasons for filing opposition papers bearing the heading of the Western Cape High Court.
Neither does it confirm that a formal application to transfer the case has been granted.
The confrontation comes as Zille seeks to strengthen the DA's political position in Johannesburg, placing her in direct conflict with Malema over the city's political history and governance.
For Malema, the dispute centres on allegations he considers damaging to his reputation and that of the EFF.
For Zille, the legal challenge presents an opportunity to defend the statements she made about the influence of the EFF during Mashaba's mayoralty.
With neither side showing any willingness to retreat, the threatened R1 million defamation action could develop into a significant legal confrontation between two of South Africa's most prominent political figures.
For now, the immediate disagreement concerns the appropriate court to hear the dispute, while the truth or falsity of Zille's allegations remains undetermined.
The political confrontation follows explosive allegations made by Zille during a television interview, in which she accused Malema of exerting improper influence over the City of Johannesburg during former mayor Herman Mashaba's administration.
Malema, who is threatening a R1 million defamation lawsuit, insists that the dispute should be heard in Johannesburg, where he says the alleged defamatory statements were made and where the events discussed took place.
On Monday, Malema published a copy of Zille's Notice of Opposition on social media platform X, drawing attention to the document's reference to the Western Cape Division of the High Court in Cape Town.
The document identifies Malema as the first applicant, the EFF as the second applicant and Zille as the respondent.
Malema interpreted the filing as an attempt to move the legal battle away from Johannesburg.
"We are suing her in Johannesburg, but she insists that the case be heard in Cape Town. What does she know about that court that gives her such confidence?" Malema wrote.
He questioned why Zille, who is seeking to become Johannesburg's mayor, would prefer proceedings in Cape Town when the dispute concerns the governance of Johannesburg.
"She made these nonsensical remarks here in Johannesburg about Johannesburg, and she is a mayoral candidate here. Yet she wants to run to the Cape Town High Court," he said.
"One day, the truth will come out. We will fight this case where the alleged conduct took place."
The Notice of Opposition has intensified the disagreement, although the document alone does not establish that a court has ordered the matter transferred or determined which division has jurisdiction.
The dispute began following Zille's appearance on eNCA on Sunday, November 8, when she made a series of allegations concerning Malema's alleged influence over Johannesburg's municipal administration between 2016 and 2019.
During the interview, Zille characterised Mashaba, who served as Johannesburg mayor during that period, as effectively operating as "the EFF mayor" to maintain his position.
She alleged that Mashaba had allowed Malema to dictate important municipal decisions and influence appointments and contracts within the city.
Among the allegations was a claim that Malema had effectively captured City Power, Johannesburg's municipal electricity utility.
Zille also alleged that Malema influenced a municipal fleet tender to benefit companies she described as his fronts.
She further claimed that Malema had directed the appointment of Shadrack Sibiya as head of Johannesburg's anti-corruption unit.
The allegations have not been established in court, and Malema has rejected them as defamatory.
Malema Demands Apology and Retraction
Following the interview, Malema instructed his lawyers, England Slabbert Attorneys, to issue a formal letter of demand to Zille.
Malema's legal representatives argued that the statements were calculated to damage his reputation and political standing.
They demanded that Zille withdraw the allegations in full, issue a public apology and provide a written undertaking that she would not repeat them.
Zille was given until the close of business on November 11 to comply.
However, the former DA federal leader refused to withdraw her statements.
Her lawyers, Minde Schapiro & Smith Inc., responded with a brief but uncompromising rejection of Malema's demands.
"We have received your letter dated 9th November 2026. The answer to all your client's demands is: No. See you in court."
The response signalled Zille's willingness to defend her remarks through legal proceedings rather than issue the apology sought by Malema.
The dispute has now expanded beyond the substance of Zille's allegations to include disagreement over where the legal proceedings should take place.
Malema maintains that Johannesburg is the appropriate venue because the remarks concerned the city's administration and were allegedly made there.
He also argues that Zille's status as the DA's Johannesburg mayoral candidate makes her preference for Cape Town particularly questionable.
However, the legal question of jurisdiction would ultimately depend on the applicable court rules, the parties' connections to the relevant jurisdictions and the circumstances surrounding the proceedings.
The available information does not establish Zille's legal reasons for filing opposition papers bearing the heading of the Western Cape High Court.
Neither does it confirm that a formal application to transfer the case has been granted.
The confrontation comes as Zille seeks to strengthen the DA's political position in Johannesburg, placing her in direct conflict with Malema over the city's political history and governance.
For Malema, the dispute centres on allegations he considers damaging to his reputation and that of the EFF.
For Zille, the legal challenge presents an opportunity to defend the statements she made about the influence of the EFF during Mashaba's mayoralty.
With neither side showing any willingness to retreat, the threatened R1 million defamation action could develop into a significant legal confrontation between two of South Africa's most prominent political figures.
For now, the immediate disagreement concerns the appropriate court to hear the dispute, while the truth or falsity of Zille's allegations remains undetermined.
Source - iol
Join the discussion
Loading comments…