News / Local
Swearing in of Khupe and her MDC-T allies as MPs, Senators challenged
02 Dec 2020 at 01:36hrs | Views
A Kwekwe man has sued the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (Zec) seeking to nullify the swearing into Parliament of MDC-T leader Thokozani Khupe and 14 MPs from her party following the recalls of MDC Alliance legislators.
In a High Court application, Charles Madhiwa cited Zec and its chairperson Priscilla Chigumba, Khupe, the MDC-T and the 14 legislators as respondents.
Khupe was sworn in together with her allies Memory Munochinzwa, January Sawuke, Lindani Moyo, Sipho Makone, Yvonne Musarurwa and Lwazi Sibanda after the recall of the MDC Alliance legislators.
Others who took up seats in the Senate are Khaliphani Phugeni, Piniel Denga, Chief Ndlovu, Nomalanga Khumalo, Teti Chisorochengwe, Gertrude Moyo, Tamani Moyo and Molly Dorothy Ndlovu.
Madhiwa, who voted in Mbizo constituency during the 2018 general elections, said Zec could only fill proportional representation vacancies in Parliament with with members of the party previously holding the seat.
He said according to the Constitution, members of independent commissions are prohibited from exercising their functions in a partisan manner to "further the interests of any political party or cause; prejudice the interests of any political party or cause; or violate fundamental rights or freedoms of any person".
"As voters in 2018, I and other voters had to choose whom we would vote for. We could choose a candidate sponsored either by MDC-T or by MDC Alliance in an election, but not for a candidate sponsored by both, as those did not exist," Madhiwa argues.
"Hence everyone, including myself, who voted validly in that election had made a choice and clearly shown the party (or independent) we wanted to hold a seat."
Madhiwa said following recalls of MDC Alliance MPs, their vacancies ought to have been filled by persons belonging to the same party as theirs in compliance with Section 157 of the Constitution.
Madhiwa and several other citizens filed their objections with Zec on September 1 which were allegedly ignored and on October 2, Chigumba published in the Government Gazette a list of MDC-T members who were scheduled to fill the positions that had become vacant after the recalls.
"I humbly submit that the proceedings of Zec and the chairperson and the resultant decision to accept hook, line and sinker the communication from Parliament advising of the recalls, acting on that advice, and proceeding to invite the MDC-T, which only had two legislators in Parliament, to submit nominees for the replacement of the 15 legislators from MDC Alliance, was grossly irregular.
"I further submit that the Zec and the chairperson were irrational in this decision, in the sense that they arrived at a decision so outrageous in its defiance of logic or accepted moral standards that no sensible person who has applied his mind to the question to be decided could have arrived at it," he argued.
The matter is yet to be set down for hearing.
In a High Court application, Charles Madhiwa cited Zec and its chairperson Priscilla Chigumba, Khupe, the MDC-T and the 14 legislators as respondents.
Khupe was sworn in together with her allies Memory Munochinzwa, January Sawuke, Lindani Moyo, Sipho Makone, Yvonne Musarurwa and Lwazi Sibanda after the recall of the MDC Alliance legislators.
Others who took up seats in the Senate are Khaliphani Phugeni, Piniel Denga, Chief Ndlovu, Nomalanga Khumalo, Teti Chisorochengwe, Gertrude Moyo, Tamani Moyo and Molly Dorothy Ndlovu.
Madhiwa, who voted in Mbizo constituency during the 2018 general elections, said Zec could only fill proportional representation vacancies in Parliament with with members of the party previously holding the seat.
He said according to the Constitution, members of independent commissions are prohibited from exercising their functions in a partisan manner to "further the interests of any political party or cause; prejudice the interests of any political party or cause; or violate fundamental rights or freedoms of any person".
"As voters in 2018, I and other voters had to choose whom we would vote for. We could choose a candidate sponsored either by MDC-T or by MDC Alliance in an election, but not for a candidate sponsored by both, as those did not exist," Madhiwa argues.
"Hence everyone, including myself, who voted validly in that election had made a choice and clearly shown the party (or independent) we wanted to hold a seat."
Madhiwa said following recalls of MDC Alliance MPs, their vacancies ought to have been filled by persons belonging to the same party as theirs in compliance with Section 157 of the Constitution.
Madhiwa and several other citizens filed their objections with Zec on September 1 which were allegedly ignored and on October 2, Chigumba published in the Government Gazette a list of MDC-T members who were scheduled to fill the positions that had become vacant after the recalls.
"I humbly submit that the proceedings of Zec and the chairperson and the resultant decision to accept hook, line and sinker the communication from Parliament advising of the recalls, acting on that advice, and proceeding to invite the MDC-T, which only had two legislators in Parliament, to submit nominees for the replacement of the 15 legislators from MDC Alliance, was grossly irregular.
"I further submit that the Zec and the chairperson were irrational in this decision, in the sense that they arrived at a decision so outrageous in its defiance of logic or accepted moral standards that no sensible person who has applied his mind to the question to be decided could have arrived at it," he argued.
The matter is yet to be set down for hearing.
Source - dailynews
