News / Local
Zimbabwe accused of blocking nurses from taking jobs abroad
09 Nov 2023 at 00:59hrs | Views
Struggling to survive on her meagre salary, Zimbabwean nurse Jane decided to start a new life abroad but, one year after landing a job in Britain, she is still waiting to pack her bags.
Jane is not alone. Zimbabwean nurses eager to escape deepening poverty say their government is barring them from pursuing opportunities overseas as it seeks to stem a brain drain of health workers.
"The government is holding me to ransom now," said Jane, 35, who only used her first name for fear of reprisals.
"I'm really worried I might not be able to leave," added the single mother-of-three who can no longer afford to eat lunch as sky-high inflation sabotages her finances.
Nurses say the authorities are frustrating their efforts to migrate by failing to provide a crucial document confirming their professional status without which they cannot take up overseas jobs.
The Health Ministry took over the issuing of "verification letters" early last year from the Nurses Council of Zimbabwe – the profession's regulatory body – which used to turn them around within days.
Unions in the southern African country estimate that thousands of nurses are affected.
Simbarashe Tafirenyika, president of the Zimbabwe Urban and Rural Council Nurses Workers Union, said some ministry officials were exploiting the situation by demanding hefty bribes to expedite documents.
The government, which has also doubled the document application fee to $300, did not respond to requests for comment, but ministers have repeatedly voiced concern over the exodus of doctors and nurses abroad.
Vice President Constantino Chiwenga, who has announced plans to criminalise the foreign recruitment of health staff, says it is wrong that Zimbabwe spends vast sums training health workers only for them to be poached by richer countries.
But nurses say it is unfair for the government to stop them leaving when many of them earn less than $100 a month.=
RED LIST
More than 4,000 health workers, including more than 2,600 nurses, left Zimbabwe in 2021 and 2022, according to official statistics.
Traditional destinations include Canada, Australia and Britain where the starting salary for a nurse is about £28,400 ($34,490).
The World Health Organization this year added Zimbabwe to a "red list" of countries with pressing health worker shortages.
In 2020, Zimbabwe had 2.1 nurses and midwives per 1,000 people, less than a quarter of the number in Britain, according to the latest World Bank data.
Britain, which relies heavily on overseas trained nurses to plug its own staff shortages, has stopped actively recruiting from Zimbabwe. However, this does not prevent nurses applying for jobs directly.
More than 4,330 nurses trained in Zimbabwe are registered with Britain's Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC).
A spokeswoman for NMC said it was aware of the issue with verification letters in Zimbabwe although some were still coming through.
Union president Tafirenyika said nurses were also migrating without verification letters to do non-nursing jobs.
He said some were even taking short first aid courses in order to get an internationally recognised "nurse aid" certificate – a route to less skilled jobs in health and social care.
STRIKE BAN
Jane, who has 10 years' experience, works at a hospital in the capital Harare. But her $200 monthly salary does not cover her bills so she also sells clothes and perfumes online.
Other nurses she knows juggle hospital shifts with selling clothes and groceries illegally on the streets where they are often chased by police.
"They endure all this to put food on the table," Jane said. "Some nurses spend the whole day without eating anything at work."
A significant problem for nurses is that their salary is paid in a mix of US dollars and Zimbabwean dollars.
With most shops and businesses charging in US dollars, nurses have to convert the portion paid in local currency, which has plunged in value this year.
Jane said 5% of her salary vanished in bank charges and a quarter went on commuting to and from her home in Harare's outskirts.
Thousands of nurses and doctors went on strike last year demanding a major pay raise and calling for their wages to be paid entirely in US dollars.
In January, Zimbabwe banned healthcare workers from striking for more than three days, introducing penalties of up to six months in jail.
PATIENTS PAY FOR OWN DRUGS
Nurses said they were also frustrated working in a broken health system with little opportunity to further their careers.
Hospitals not only lack equipment, including ventilators and X-ray machines, but even painkillers and rubber gloves can be in short supply.
Nurses said patients often had to buy their own drugs.
"The situation is really pitiful," said Jane. "There's no equipment for some procedures leading to a lot of cancellations.
"Women are delivering babies without linen and have to sleep on the floor after giving birth. There is no lignocaine (local anaesthetic) if they need stitches so they have to buy it themselves."
Tanaka, 28, who works at another Harare hospital, is also demoralised.
"It's tough to ask patients to buy their own drugs – imagine, even paracetamol!" she said.
"We work without PPE (protective clothing). I fear for my health. Enough is enough."
Tanaka had hoped to relocate to Britain in the summer after receiving a job offer last year but is still awaiting her verification letter.
"I was afraid when they said they want to bring in a law to bar us from going. That is scary," said Tanaka, who only gave her first name.
Migrating is not cheap. She has already spent $1,200 on taking a professional exam required to be able to work in Britain and on other expenses.
She also needs to pay for an English language test and TB test but has put these on hold amid uncertainty over whether the government will issue her document.
Tanaka, who has a 5-year-old daughter, knows life in Britain is expensive – average monthly rents top £2,000 in parts of London – but she says she cannot afford to stay in Zimbabwe.
"I take home a paltry $200. It's not enough to feed my family or even buy clothes for my kid. I have no choice," she said.
(Additional reporting by Emma Batha; Writing by Emma Batha. Editing by Clar Ni Chonghaile.
Jane is not alone. Zimbabwean nurses eager to escape deepening poverty say their government is barring them from pursuing opportunities overseas as it seeks to stem a brain drain of health workers.
"The government is holding me to ransom now," said Jane, 35, who only used her first name for fear of reprisals.
"I'm really worried I might not be able to leave," added the single mother-of-three who can no longer afford to eat lunch as sky-high inflation sabotages her finances.
Nurses say the authorities are frustrating their efforts to migrate by failing to provide a crucial document confirming their professional status without which they cannot take up overseas jobs.
The Health Ministry took over the issuing of "verification letters" early last year from the Nurses Council of Zimbabwe – the profession's regulatory body – which used to turn them around within days.
Unions in the southern African country estimate that thousands of nurses are affected.
Simbarashe Tafirenyika, president of the Zimbabwe Urban and Rural Council Nurses Workers Union, said some ministry officials were exploiting the situation by demanding hefty bribes to expedite documents.
The government, which has also doubled the document application fee to $300, did not respond to requests for comment, but ministers have repeatedly voiced concern over the exodus of doctors and nurses abroad.
Vice President Constantino Chiwenga, who has announced plans to criminalise the foreign recruitment of health staff, says it is wrong that Zimbabwe spends vast sums training health workers only for them to be poached by richer countries.
But nurses say it is unfair for the government to stop them leaving when many of them earn less than $100 a month.=
RED LIST
More than 4,000 health workers, including more than 2,600 nurses, left Zimbabwe in 2021 and 2022, according to official statistics.
Traditional destinations include Canada, Australia and Britain where the starting salary for a nurse is about £28,400 ($34,490).
The World Health Organization this year added Zimbabwe to a "red list" of countries with pressing health worker shortages.
In 2020, Zimbabwe had 2.1 nurses and midwives per 1,000 people, less than a quarter of the number in Britain, according to the latest World Bank data.
Britain, which relies heavily on overseas trained nurses to plug its own staff shortages, has stopped actively recruiting from Zimbabwe. However, this does not prevent nurses applying for jobs directly.
More than 4,330 nurses trained in Zimbabwe are registered with Britain's Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC).
A spokeswoman for NMC said it was aware of the issue with verification letters in Zimbabwe although some were still coming through.
Union president Tafirenyika said nurses were also migrating without verification letters to do non-nursing jobs.
He said some were even taking short first aid courses in order to get an internationally recognised "nurse aid" certificate – a route to less skilled jobs in health and social care.
STRIKE BAN
Jane, who has 10 years' experience, works at a hospital in the capital Harare. But her $200 monthly salary does not cover her bills so she also sells clothes and perfumes online.
"They endure all this to put food on the table," Jane said. "Some nurses spend the whole day without eating anything at work."
A significant problem for nurses is that their salary is paid in a mix of US dollars and Zimbabwean dollars.
With most shops and businesses charging in US dollars, nurses have to convert the portion paid in local currency, which has plunged in value this year.
Jane said 5% of her salary vanished in bank charges and a quarter went on commuting to and from her home in Harare's outskirts.
Thousands of nurses and doctors went on strike last year demanding a major pay raise and calling for their wages to be paid entirely in US dollars.
In January, Zimbabwe banned healthcare workers from striking for more than three days, introducing penalties of up to six months in jail.
PATIENTS PAY FOR OWN DRUGS
Nurses said they were also frustrated working in a broken health system with little opportunity to further their careers.
Hospitals not only lack equipment, including ventilators and X-ray machines, but even painkillers and rubber gloves can be in short supply.
Nurses said patients often had to buy their own drugs.
"The situation is really pitiful," said Jane. "There's no equipment for some procedures leading to a lot of cancellations.
"Women are delivering babies without linen and have to sleep on the floor after giving birth. There is no lignocaine (local anaesthetic) if they need stitches so they have to buy it themselves."
Tanaka, 28, who works at another Harare hospital, is also demoralised.
"It's tough to ask patients to buy their own drugs – imagine, even paracetamol!" she said.
"We work without PPE (protective clothing). I fear for my health. Enough is enough."
Tanaka had hoped to relocate to Britain in the summer after receiving a job offer last year but is still awaiting her verification letter.
"I was afraid when they said they want to bring in a law to bar us from going. That is scary," said Tanaka, who only gave her first name.
Migrating is not cheap. She has already spent $1,200 on taking a professional exam required to be able to work in Britain and on other expenses.
She also needs to pay for an English language test and TB test but has put these on hold amid uncertainty over whether the government will issue her document.
Tanaka, who has a 5-year-old daughter, knows life in Britain is expensive – average monthly rents top £2,000 in parts of London – but she says she cannot afford to stay in Zimbabwe.
"I take home a paltry $200. It's not enough to feed my family or even buy clothes for my kid. I have no choice," she said.
(Additional reporting by Emma Batha; Writing by Emma Batha. Editing by Clar Ni Chonghaile.
Source - Thomson Reuters Foundation
